| 1st Period Play-by-Play |
| | End of period [45:00]. |
| [43:39] | Shot by BUFM Pa Lu, SAVE Joe Gonzalez. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [41:49] | Shot by AUMS2018 Adam Taylor WIDE. |
| [40:00] | Shot by AUMS2018 Raquan Hinds WIDE. |
| [39:48] | Shot by BUFM Theo Pencic BLOCKED. |
| [37:56] | Shot by BUFM Zakaria Shaibi HIGH. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [33:57] | BUFM substitution: Jake Ferry for Ali Shawish. |
| | Foul on Buffalo State. |
| [31:42] | BUFM substitution: Abdul Salem for Ramazani Juma. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [28:52] | Shot by BUFM Ali Shawish WIDE. |
| [28:45] | Yellow card on AUMS2018 Michael Villafane. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Charles Hawkins for Casey Hyer. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Michael Villafane for Keenan Kasperek. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Zachary Gloskin for Gavin Harrington. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Raquan Hinds for Kalum Holbrook. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Mason Sanborn for Jeremy Walther. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Cody Cronmiller for Tristan Williams. |
| [27:45] | AUMS2018 substitution: Adam Taylor for David Lingenfelter. |
| [24:58] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [22:35] | BUFM substitution: Zakaria Shaibi for Colin O'Keefe. |
| [22:28] | Shot by BUFM Robert Williamson HIGH. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [21:14] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| [20:25] | Shot by BUFM Ali Shawish, SAVE Joe Gonzalez. |
| [19:20] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| [16:40] | Shot by BUFM Robert Williamson WIDE. |
| | Foul on Alfred University. |
| [14:22] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| [12:48] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| [12:12] | AUMS2018 substitution: Tristan Williams for Tavian Hino. |
| [12:12] | AUMS2018 substitution: David Lingenfelter for Andrew Barnikel. |
| | Corner kick by BUFM Trevor Moreland [10:28]. |
| [10:03] | Shot by BUFM Nemanja Simic, SAVE Joe Gonzalez. |
| | *Shot from just inside box to bottom left |
| Buffalo State 1, Alfred University 0 |
| [04:54] | GOAL by BUFM Theo Pencic (FIRST GOAL), goal number 9 for season. |
| | Foul on Buffalo State. |
| | Corner kick by BUFM Trevor Moreland [02:51]. |
| [02:28] | Shot by BUFM Ali Shawish BLOCKED. |
| [01:30] | Shot by BUFM Ali Shawish WIDE. |
| [00:45] | Offside against Buffalo State. |
| [00:00] | Dylan Guarino at goalie for Buffalo State. |
| [00:00] | Joe Gonzalez at goalie for Alfred University. |